Propane tank exchange vs. refill — which is better for you?

Jul 14, 2022 | Cost of Propane Gas, Cylinder Refill, Cylinder Refill, Franger Gas, Propane, Propane Tips, Refill Tank, Refueling Station

Home » Blog » Propane tank exchange vs. refill — which is better for you?

Should you Refill or Exchange your Propane Tank this Summer?

Whether you are preparing for a backyard barbecue or a road trip in the camper with the family – when you find that your small propane tank is empty, a decision must be made. Should you refill your propane tank, or exchange it for a new one?

The choice between propane tank exchange versus refill has two main arguments: convenience and cost savings. Without a doubt, refilling your propane tank is more cost-effective – but let’s take a closer look at the choices.

Refilling your Propane Tank – Pros and Cons

PROS

  • It’s cheaper.  On average, it is about $1.76 per gallon cheaper to refill a propane tank versus exchanging. Refilling your own propane tank costs about $3-$4 per gallon while exchanging at a third-party retailer is usually around $5-6 per gallon.
  • When you refill your tank at Franger Gas, we guarantee you get a full tank every time. You will also avoid flat rate fills. That means you pay only for the gas we put in your cylinder, which we measure by weight.
  • Unmeasured Quantity. Sure, you know that it is propane, but you also aren’t exactly sure how much is really in it. Exchange tanks are partially empty to allow room for the gas to expand, but exchange tanks are only filled about ¾ of the way. An exchange tank is only guaranteed to be about 15 pounds out of a max of 20 pounds. A refill tank can be filled more, and the cost per gallon is quite a bit lower. 
  • You may not be able to. If you have an older propane tank that has not been inspected in a long time, you will likely not be able to exchange it. Instead, you will be left having to purchase an entirely new tank and have it filled. 

CONS:

  • Convenience. Instead of finding a fresh tank of propane when you need it at your nearest hardware store, gas station, or grocery market, you’ll have to take your tank to a retail location set up for refills, during normally scheduled business hours. 

However, there’s likely a Franger Gas refilling location near your neighborhood! Contact us to find the location closest to you or view our refilling locations herehttps://frangergas.com/locations/.

Exchanging your Propane Tank

PROS:

  • Convenience. Exchanging your propane tank is quick and easy. You can have a spontaneous barbecue, and quickly find the propane you need just moments before guests arrive and the grilling begins. The process only requires you to drop off your old tank and pick up a new one. 
  • Exchanged propane tanks are regularly inspected, so you’ll know that the tank you pick up has a lot of life left. Remember – Franger Gas can inspect and recertify your existing tank for you!

CONS:

  • Less cost-efficient. Exchanging a propane tank can be less cost-efficient in several ways: higher price per gallon ($5-6 vs. $3-4 per gallon), not a full fill – and the potential of not using all of the propane prior to the exchange.

Find a Franger Gas location near you

Whether you choose to refill or exchange your propane tank, propane is the best way to fuel your summer. Propane is an affordable, easy-to-use, and efficient fuel. Contact Franger Gas today to for a propane tank refill – and don’t miss a beat in powering your summer activities!

It’s time to save on your energy bill with GPP. Act now!

At Franger Gas, we want you to have confidence in our propane service – and peace of mind when it comes to cost. Our Guaranteed Price Program can help you plan your spending and offer predictability for your energy bill.

How to Prep your Propane Home for Fall

Now that fall is here, it’s time to think about what you can do to get your home and propane appliances ready for colder weather. Franger Gas is here to give you some great tips on how to prep your propane home for fall and winter.

Benefits of fueling your whole home with propane

Propane is a versatile and all-in-one energy fuel package for maximum efficiency, performance and comfort, both indoors and outdoors.

Propane Safety Tips during a Power Outage

Propane can help you avoid headaches and frustrations with a power outages, but there are still safety precautions we want customers to take.

How to recertify your propane tank

Propane tanks are good for 12 years from the date of manufacture. After that, propane tanks need inspection and recertification every 5 years.

Switching Propane Companies to Franger Gas in 3 Easy Steps

Switching your propane provider to Franger Gas is simple and rewarding. In just three easy steps, you can have the best propane service around.

Act now for savings on your Propane Bill

Energy prices don’t have to be terrifying. Our Guaranteed Price Program is a budget billing program to give you a predictable propane bill.

Preparing for the Rising Cost of Energy and Battling Pricing Shock

Energy costs are rising – and the price of heating your home is higher than ever. Regain control with propane and smarter habits with help from Franger Gas.

Choosing the Right Heating Source for your Home

Choosing the right heating source for your home is a big decision. Read on to discover if natural gas, propane or electric heating is best.

Refer A Friend to Franger Gas

As the coldest months of winter approach, it’s typical to begin thinking (or rethinking) your home heating situation. We all want to be assured that our loved ones will be warm and safe when winter is at its harshest. Our Refer a Friend program can do just that! Keep reading to learn the many benefits of propane as your heat source — and how to Refer a Friend to our program.

Tips For Winter Propane Delivery

We know heating your home and keeping you family warm and safe becomes a top priority when wind chill and temperatures drop, and snow and ice become an issue. As your prepare for winter propane deliveries, we have some tips and advice for winter propane deliveries.

Franger Gas: Looking Back at 2021

What a year 2021 has been! We celebrated our 75th Anniversary and have so much to be grateful for as we head into 2022.  Our customers have given all of us at Franger Gas Company so many reasons to say “Thanks!” You continue to trust us to provide your...

Let’s Celebrate 75 years of Franger Gas!

We are thrilled to be celebrating our 75th year in business! As we look back with pride at our company history full of success – we wanted to share some thoughts about the journey.

The difference between Natural Gas and Propane

What is the difference between natural gas and propane? Is switching from propane to natural gas the right move for your home?

Finding a Trusted Wholesale Propane Supplier

Franger Gas Wholesale has been the go-to wholesale propane supplier for retail propane marketers and farmers for over 75 years.

Remote Propane Tank Monitoring: A Solution for Our Propane Customers

Franger Gas offers remote monitoring services for commercial, industrial, wholesale, and residential customers with propane gas tanks.

Budget billing with Franger Gas saves time and money

***Budget billing sign up is over for 2021.*** Ready for convenient, predictable, guaranteed pricing you can count on for your energy needs? Set up a budget billing account with us and know your monthly propane bill amount will be the same each month. Budget billing...

Reinvesting in the future with a focus on propane supply

How does a propane company continue to grow in strength and reliability? By continuously sourcing consistent supplies of fuel.

That’s what we do every day at Franger Gas Company. We saw a potential supply problem following the winter of 2013-2014 and partnered with a supplier to build the Mentone Propane Rail Terminal.

Grateful beyond words

As we come to the end of one of the strangest years ever, this is the perfect time to reflect on a word that doesn’t get used often enough: gratitude.  Our customers have given all of us at Franger Gas Company so many reasons to say “Thanks!” You continue to trust us...

Propane – the smart energy choice to temporarily heat your construction site this winter

Does your construction project timeline include work during cold weather? Temporary propane-powered heat keeps your project on schedule, even during the coldest months of the year. 8 reasons to choose propane for temporary heat Why propane? It's a clean-burning, green...

How to get your propane tank ready for winter

Keep your family warm and safe. Here are simple tips to keep your propane tank in top condition and ready to fuel the heat this winter.

Bulk Tank Propane Storage smart move for wholesale customers

Let our experts help upgrade your bulk tank propane storage or begin a bulk plant construction project. Contact Franger Gas today.

Simple lessons about propane gas supply and demand

A disruption in our energy supply can be concerning. Franger Gas works hard to ensure reliable supply, no matter what happens with demand.

7 tips to help you brush up on propane gas grilling

Brush up on propane gas grilling with tips from Franger Gas to make sure your grill and fuel supply are ready for barbecue time.

Franger Gas responds to COVID-19 with precaution

Franger Gas Company is responding to the circumstances surrounding the novel Coronavirus labeled COVID-19, and how it impacts our business and our customers. Your safety, and the safety of our employees, is what matters most at this time.

Budget billing for convenient, predictable payments. Don’t miss out!

Note: budget billing sign-ups have ended for 2020 Sign up now to start budget billing on May 1 **Please note, if you are already on the budget, there is no need to sign up again.  You will automatically be re-enrolled for the next season beginning May 1.**   At...

What is propane?

Propane is a safe and widely used fuel. It is nontoxic and produces minimal emissions. Propane is produced from both natural gas processing and crude oil refining, in roughly equal amounts.Propane is a hydrocarbon and is sometimes referred to as liquefied petroleum...

Winter is coming. Are you ready?

Prepare your Propane Tank for Winter with these tips from Franger Gas
In Indiana and Michigan, our home heating customers know two things for sure about the winter months – winters here are brutal, and propane does the job when it comes to keeping your family warm.

What happens if you run out of propane?

Don't run out of gas! Serious safety hazards, including fire or explosion, can result. It also could lead to frozen pipes, out-of-gas charges and inconveniences. Air and moisture may cause rust... Air and moisture could get into an empty or depleted storage tank,...

Leaks: What to do if you smell gas

1. No flame or sparks Immediately put out smoking materials and other open flames. Do not operate lights, appliances, telephones, or cell phones. Flames or sparks from these sources can trigger an explosion or a fire. 2. Leave the area immediately! Get everyone out of...